Criterion

Fellini's segment on Spirits of the Dead

The Toby Dammit segment is also available in Criterion boxset but seems to be SD, so Arrow Blu-ray > Plaion Blu-ray > Criterion boxset Blu-ray

Italy Plaion 4K Blu-ray

Criterion = BFI, both HD resto: source

Criterion, 4k transfer

Criterion 2k transfer

2004 MGM DVD

MoC = Criterion

But better extras

2022 Criterion 4K Blu-ray

?

Criterion boxset but awful compression

Carlotta FR Blu-ray

FiM encode w/o English subtitles; Criterion boxset one has awful compression. review

Rohmer Potemkine set

Rohmer Potemkine set vs Criterion set?

Netherlands 2006 Homescreen DVD

Criterion Blu-ray is slightly better than MoC Blu-ray: while both are from a 4K restoration approved by director, MoC is more sharpened but gamma is flatter see caps

Paramount DVD and potentially Paramount LaserDisc

Paramount DVD and potentially Paramount LaserDisc see blah-ray

Criterion and MoC Blu-ray has the same audio, and additional (destructive) hiss reduction was applied, and one segment was made significantly louder.

Also, every home video release except the 1982 Paramount VHS cassette replaces Wild Man Fischer's 'Merry-Go-Round' in the roller derby scene with a version of 'Sweet Georgia Brown' by Brother Bones. Two very different songs, and one must assume that the tone of the scene has changed considerably

Included as extras in the Criterion 8½ Blu-ray. Looks like SD source, and in a very rough quality.

France ARTE

France ARTE has Costa-Gavras Coffret boxset Germany/Spain also have releases

Criterion 4k resto

2007 Criterion DVD/2011 StudioCanal Blu-ray

2017 StudioCanal Blu-ray might(?) be the same.

MoC > Criterion

MoC

Criterion resto bad? but no other BDs

1990 Criterion LaserDisc

(still not great)

Criterion 4K Blu-ray is similar but has a short scene where the hum from machinery at the oil rig has been attentuated. It's a decent improvement over the previous disc which had considerable bass reduction.